Close Menu
What The FinanceWhat The Finance
    What's Hot

    Whistleblowers Unmask Schwab’s Toxic WEF Secrets

    April 25, 2025

    Capital One-Discover Merger Reshaping the Credit Card Industry

    April 24, 2025

    Michael Saylor’s Strategy New $286 Million Bitcoin Purchase

    April 15, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    X (Twitter) Facebook YouTube
    What The FinanceWhat The Finance
    Donate
    • NewsWire

      Capital One-Discover Merger Reshaping the Credit Card Industry

      April 24, 2025

      Michael Saylor’s Strategy New $286 Million Bitcoin Purchase

      April 15, 2025

      Breaking Down the U.S. Budget

      February 14, 2025

      The Financial Impact of Mizotakis Resigning in Greece

      February 1, 2025

      Incoming US President Shocks with $TRUMP Memecoin Launch

      January 18, 2025
    • Bitcoin

      The Rise of State-Level Strategic Bitcoin Reserves

      February 19, 2025

      How Oklahoma is Embracing Bitcoin with Legislation

      January 15, 2025

      Without Bitcoin: A Grim Vision of the Financial Future

      January 6, 2025

      Rumble Video Creators to Be Paid in Bitcoin

      December 24, 2024

      French Politician Advocates for EU Bitcoin Reserve

      December 17, 2024
    • Crypto

      The DAO Governance Battle Between Corporations & Blockchain Rebels

      October 25, 2024

      Altcoin Season Coming to an End? BTC Dominance & Institutions

      September 27, 2024

      Is Tether a $118 Billion Dollar Scandal Waiting to Happen?

      September 18, 2024

      Uncovering North Korean IT Workers in DeFi Scam

      August 16, 2024

      Navigating the Crypto Market: Avoiding Liquidation & Bull Traps

      July 24, 2024
    • Stocks

      NASDAQ 100 Welcomes Bitcoin Through MicroStrategy

      December 14, 2024

      Master the Time Value of Money Financial Concept

      December 9, 2024

      MicroStrategy Convertible Debt Expansion Sparks Stock Surge

      November 21, 2024

      Financial Ratios Guide to Measuring Business Performance

      November 18, 2024

      The Highest Paid CEOs of 2024

      October 1, 2024
    • Global Economy

      Whistleblowers Unmask Schwab’s Toxic WEF Secrets

      April 25, 2025

      Tariff Tensions Drive Market Volatility

      April 9, 2025

      Red in Name Only: Labour’s War on the UK Working Class

      March 18, 2025

      AI, Robotics & the Future of Cheap Production

      January 20, 2025

      Can Milei Inflation Gamble Hurt Argentina’s Future?

      January 13, 2025
    • TradFi
      • Investment Ideas
      • Forex
      • Commodities
      • Best Deals
    • Markets
      • Cryptocurrency Prices
      • Fear & Greed Index
      • World Market Indices
      • US Stock Market
      • Live Forex Rates
      • S&P 500
      • Gold
    What The FinanceWhat The Finance
    Home»Satoshi»Dr Bitcoin Podcast: The Mysterious Pineapple Hack Case
    Dr Bitcoin podcast
    Satoshi

    Dr Bitcoin Podcast: The Mysterious Pineapple Hack Case

    January 23, 2024No Comments7 Mins Read
    Share
    Twitter Facebook Reddit LinkedIn Telegram

    Background

    The Pineapple Hack case, a significant event for crypto, revolves around a series of complex legal and technical issues that have garnered widespread attention in the community. At the heart of this case is Craig Wright, a contentious figure in the crypto community, known for his infamous claim to be Satoshi Nakamoto, the enigmatic creator of Bitcoin. The case emerged from a series of alleged digital currency thefts, leading to a high-stakes legal battle involving Wright and several entities in the crypto space, in this case mostly Bitcoin developers.

    The appellant in the case is Tulip Trading Limited, a company incorporated in Seychelles, while the respondents include several individuals who are developers and promoters within the Bitcoin community, including Wladimir Jasper van der Laan, Jonas Schnelli, Pieter Wuille, among others.

    The legal teams are led by John Wardell KC, Bobby Friedman, and Sri Carmichael from Ontier LLP representing the appellant, and James Ramsden KC from Bird & Bird LLP representing the majority of the respondents.

    The hearing took place over two days, on the 7th and 8th of December 2022, before a panel of judges consisting of Lord Justice Lewison, Lord Justice Popplewell, and Lord Justice Birss in the Royal Courts of Justice in London.

    The controversy primarily focuses on the legitimacy of Wright’s claims and the authenticity of the evidence he has presented, which has been subject to intense scrutiny and debate. The Pineapple Hack case is not just a legal dispute; it represents a critical juncture in the crypto world, raising questions about the security, ownership, and even the very nature of digital currencies.

    The unfolding of the Pineapple Hack case has been marked by dramatic twists and turns, particularly about Wright’s changing narratives and the evidence related to the hack. Key to the controversy is the role of Tulip Trading Ltd, associated with Wright, and the allegations of him presenting a false case. The legal proceedings have delved into the technical intricacies of blockchain technology and the principles of digital currency ownership and transfer.

    Case Details

    image 125

    The Court of Appeal case under review addressed whether developers involved with Bitcoin owe fiduciary duties or duties in tort to owners of the cryptocurrency.

    The appellant, Tulip Trading Limited (Tulip), associated with Dr. Craig Wright, claimed to have lost access to a significant value of Bitcoin due to a hack that compromised their private keys. Tulip argued that the defendant developers, who oversee the Bitcoin networks, could implement a software patch to restore access to Tulip’s Bitcoin, thereby suggesting that the developers owed fiduciary duties to Bitcoin owners like Tulip.

    The High Court initially ruled against Tulip, concluding there was no serious issue to be tried regarding a breach of fiduciary or tortious duty by the developers to Tulip. However, Tulip was granted permission to appeal this decision.

    Upon appeal, the Court of Appeal assessed several points:

    1. Fiduciary Duty Claim: The Court of Appeal found it arguable that Bitcoin developers, given their control over Bitcoin’s software, may owe fiduciary duties to Bitcoin owners. This was a notable divergence from the High Court’s decision, which had dismissed the idea of such a fiduciary relationship.
    2. Positive Duty to Act: The Court also considered whether developers owe a positive duty to act when presented with software bugs, highlighting that developers do indeed have a practical ability to prevent anyone else from introducing fixes. It argued that owners have, in essence, entrusted their property to the developers.
    3. Developers’ Role and Authority: The Court suggested that developers might act as fiduciaries by making discretionary decisions that affect Bitcoin owners’ property, further entrenching the idea of a potential fiduciary relationship.
    4. Anticipatory Breach: Tulip’s amended claim introduced the concept of anticipatory breach, where developers would be in breach if they did not act following a court declaration of Tulip’s ownership of the Bitcoin, a point that had not been fully considered previously.
    5. Remedies: The Court discussed the effectiveness of potential remedies and indicated that the suitable place to examine them would be at trial, not at the jurisdictional appeal stage.

    The Court concluded that Tulip’s case did raise a serious issue to be tried and that the matter should proceed to trial to establish the facts. The judgment highlighted that the decentralized governance of Bitcoin is potentially a myth and, if so, developers could owe fiduciary duties to the true owners of Bitcoin while acting in their capacity as developers.

    All three judges of the Court of Appeal agreed with this decision, thereby allowing Tulip’s appeal to proceed.

    As the case progresses, it continues to be a focal point of discussion and analysis, reflecting the evolving dynamics of law, technology, and finance in the digital age. This is what makes this podcast so fascinating to listen to.

    Dr Bitcoin Podcast

    e715dfe2 0751 46db b4d8 fc9a330aae21

    In a past episode of the “Dr Bitcoin – The Man Who Wasn’t Satoshi Nakamoto” podcast, released in December 2023, hosts Mark and Arthur delve into the complex and evolving saga surrounding the Pineapple Hack trial. This episode, titled “Pineapple Hack Update”, offers a detailed analysis of the recent developments in this high-profile case, which has captivated the attention of the cryptocurrency community and beyond.

    The Core of the Controversy: Craig Wright’s Shifting Narrative

    In this episode, the hosts scrutinize Wright’s recent actions, particularly his disavowal of evidence previously presented in the Pineapple Hack trial. This significant backtrack raises critical questions about the credibility of his claims and the integrity of the evidence he has provided.

    Furthermore, Wright’s changing story regarding the bonded courier, a key element in proving his claim to the Satoshi Nakamoto identity, is a focal point of discussion. The hosts, Mark and Arthur, known for their in-depth and critical approach, dissect these developments, offering listeners a nuanced perspective on the implications of these changes in Wright’s narrative.

    Judicial Scrutiny & the Tulip Trading Ltd Case

    Another pivotal aspect of this episode is the examination of the judge’s decision to conduct a preliminary trial. This trial aims to ascertain whether Tulip Trading Ltd, associated with Wright, has brought forth a false case. The significance of this decision cannot be overstated, as it could potentially unravel the fabric of claims and counterclaims that have been a hallmark of this saga.

    The podcast episode is not just a recount of events; it’s an analytical journey through the maze of legal, technical, and ethical issues surrounding the Pineapple Hack case. The hosts’ expertise in the field of cryptocurrency and their ability to dissect complex legal proceedings make this episode a must-listen for anyone interested in the intersection of technology, law, and digital currencies.

    Our TTL vs Bitcoin Devs update is available for all Dr Bitcoin Supporters Club members. It'll be available for the masses on the 24th. To listen now, visit https://t.co/7JlhI6C9DG.

    However, if you check your feed you'll see that June's Pineapple Hack update is free until then. pic.twitter.com/vVdveBmRJT

    — Dr Bitcoin (@DrBitcoinPod) December 21, 2023

    Engaging with the Community & Further Resources

    Listeners are encouraged to engage with the podcast community on Twitter, following @drbitcoinpod for the podcast updates. Additionally, Arthur’s in-depth articles on Craig Wright can be found at mylegacykit.medium.com, providing a more comprehensive understanding of the background and nuances of this case.

    The “Pineapple Hack Update” episode of the “Dr Bitcoin – The Man Who Wasn’t Satoshi Nakamoto” podcast is a compelling and informative piece that sheds light on one of the most controversial and complex stories in the cryptocurrency world. It’s a testament to the intricate web of technology, law, and personal narratives that continue to shape the digital currency landscape.

    Listen to the episode

    Author Profile

    Lucy Walker
    Lucy Walker
    Lucy Walker covers finance, health and beauty since 2014. She has been writing for various online publications.
    Latest entries
    • April 25, 2025Global EconomicsWhistleblowers Unmask Schwab’s Toxic WEF Secrets
    • April 9, 2025Global EconomicsTariff Tensions Drive Market Volatility
    • March 18, 2025Global EconomicsRed in Name Only: Labour’s War on the UK Working Class
    • March 7, 2025SatoshiCraig Wright Banned from UK Courts with Civil Restraint Order
    1
    Share. Twitter LinkedIn Telegram Reddit Facebook
    Previous ArticleMarmara Credit Loops Shaping Interest-Free Digital Credit
    Next Article Shadows Behind the Crypto Throne: The Alleged DCG Fraud

    Related Posts

    Craig Wright Banned from UK Courts with Civil Restraint Order

    March 7, 2025

    Trillion $ Bitcoin Lawsuit Dismissed as Court Issues Written Verdict

    December 20, 2024Updated:December 20, 2024

    Craig Wright Convicted to 1 Year in Prison for Contempt

    December 19, 2024Updated:December 19, 2024
    Add A Comment
    Leave A Reply

    Stock Ticker
    • Loading stock data...

    Whistleblowers Unmask Schwab’s Toxic WEF Secrets

    April 25, 2025

    Capital One-Discover Merger Reshaping the Credit Card Industry

    April 24, 2025

    Michael Saylor’s Strategy New $286 Million Bitcoin Purchase

    April 15, 2025

    Tariff Tensions Drive Market Volatility

    April 9, 2025
    Categories
    • Best Deals
    • Bitcoin
    • Commodities
    • Crypto
    • Forex
    • Global Economics
    • Investment Ideas
    • NewsWire
    • Satoshi
    • Stock Market
    Recent Comments
    • Bitcoin Grandad on The Aftermath: Craig Wright, BSV & nChain in Crisis
    • Peter Williamson on SUI: A Rising Force in the Blockchain World
    • Peter Williamson on Robotics Revolution 2024: A Guide to 16 Industry Leaders
    Also Check Out

    Craig Wright Banned from UK Courts with Civil Restraint Order

    March 7, 2025

    The Rise of State-Level Strategic Bitcoin Reserves

    February 19, 2025

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest sports news from SportsSite about soccer, football and tennis.

    Your source for financial news. This is not financial advice. Our opinions are independent of any financial organizations.

    2007 - 2023 | What The Finance Magazine

    We're social. Connect with us:

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn TikTok
    Top Insights

    Whistleblowers Unmask Schwab’s Toxic WEF Secrets

    April 25, 2025

    Tariff Tensions Drive Market Volatility

    April 9, 2025

    Red in Name Only: Labour’s War on the UK Working Class

    March 18, 2025
    Categories
    • Best Deals
    • Bitcoin
    • Commodities
    • Crypto
    • Forex
    • Global Economics
    • Investment Ideas
    • NewsWire
    • Satoshi
    • Stock Market
    Pages
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Get In Touch
    • Markets
    • Privacy Policy
    • Donate
    • Trending Articles

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok